Theory Of Evolution Challenged By French Chef; Cites Role Of Food And Wine
While The Theory of Evolution has received numerous challenges since Darwin proposed it, none seems to have taken the scientific community with such devastating surprise as the theory recently proposed by a French Chef from Bordeaux.
The Chef, Andre Dumier, who operates a One Star Michelin restaurant just outside the city of Bordeaux, advanced the theory after contemplating what he considers the first requirement in the various stages of evolution - the availability of food. We were fortunate in being able to arrange an exclusive Newslaugh interview. The complete text follows.
NewsLaugh: We understand you have proposed a radical revision of Darwin's Theory of Evolution. Would you please explain your theory?
Dumier: But, of course, monsieur. The great flaw in Darwin's Theory is that he puts Natural Selection before the existence of food to select.
NewsLaugh: Say, that's interesting. Can you elaborate?
Dumier: It is my pleasure to do so. To me his Theory of Evolution does not make a primary place for the absolute necessity of food. Let me explain. Do you think the fish evolved in the ocean before there was plankton for them to dine on? Of course, not. They would have starved! And, if they could not survive, how could you have Survival of the Fittest?
NewsLaugh: Do you have an alternate theory to propose?
Dumier: Oui, monsieur. Survival of the Fullest. To my mind, it is the more correct idea.
NewsLaugh: Yes, we can see your point. How do you account for the fact that animals eventually emerged from the sea and populated the land?
Dumier: Think for yourself! Do you suppose they would have crawled out onto the land if there was no food waiting for them? No, no! They went up onto the land because they knew there was food there, just waiting for them to bite into and enjoy!
NewsLaugh: May we ask how they found out it was there?
Dumier: Well, I wasn't present at the time, but I will tell you my thought. Some food got blown into the water, no doubt a delectable plant or so. Perhaps a legume. Maybe during a rainstorm a truffle got washed in. These primitive fish took a taste. They liked it and wanted more. But they couldn't go get it.
NewsLaugh: Why is that?
Dumier: Why else? They had no legs, a deficiency that brings us to how such things really evolved.
NewsLaugh: How is that?
Dumier: Think, monsieur! Since they needed legs to get to the food, they grew them. Then they walked out and chowed down.
NewsLaugh: How do you think they eventually became exclusively land-based animals?
Dumier: For the same reason that you go to the grocery store every week. There is a lot of food and you can pick it up without having to be concerned that somebody else will snatch it out of your hand. They noticed they were the only diners on land, whereas in the primal ocean, there were millions of fish, competing for every morsel and a big one might even dine on you. But on the land? No, such worries. There they beheld, not only the plentiful food, but, at least for the short term, the absence of competition for it.
NewsLaugh: So your theory is that evolution was originally driven by the availability of food?
Dumier: But, of course! Look even at the world today. Wherever there is a speck of food, for example, even lichen in the tiniest crack in a rock, some little bug or bird evolves to eat it. But first must come the food!
NewsLaugh: How do you account for the evolution of homo sapiens?
Dumier: My good man, look for yourself! The proof is right before your eyes. You have seen the famous cave paintings at Lascaux?
NewsLaugh: Yes, we're familiar with them.
Dumier: Well, then, think about the famous Hall of the Bulls. Why do you think those primitive inhabitants were drawing bulls? Because they like bulls? No, because they were thinking about steak for dinner! But, actually, food is only the more primitive aspect of my theory.
NewsLaugh: Please, elaborate.
Dumier: When the Neanderthals or some earlier hominids discovered fire, what do you think is the first thing they thought of, eh? Voila! Now we can cook our food! No more raw meat for us. So they began to roast and broil! Do you know how different that is? Homo sapiens is the only creature who cooks his food! Fish can't cook in the water, because if they try to boil it they get poached. And can you imagine, for example, foxes gathered around a fire, roasting a rack of lamb? No, cooking is purely an aspect of human behavior.
NewsLaugh: Yes, that's true. But certainly there's more to the evolution of man - and woman - than food?
Dumier: Of course, of course. And that brings us to the big question? The final step toward homo sapies. These primitives asked, 'What next?' At this point, they were ready, in Hegelian terms, to make the next big leap in self-realization.
NewsLaugh: What was that?
Dumier: They noticed grapes. They liked to eat them and savor the juice, but there is, after all, so little of the delectable nectar in a single grape. So they decided to squeeze a batch of them to have more. Then a female - or perhaps a less-warlike male who was tending the cave while the strong guys were out hunting for dinner - accidentally, or perhaps as an inspiration, dropped in some yeast. And what do you think? Voila again! Only this time vin! They discovered wine.
NewsLaugh: Hmm, I suppose it might well have happened that way.
Dumier: Yes, yes, why do you think we still age wine in a cave? But now you see the entire picture, do you not? There they are, these ancestors of ours, sitting in a cave around a fire, roasting steaks and drinking wine. How much of a step do you think it is beyond these nascent gourmets to homo sapiens as we know and feed him today?
NewsLaugh: Yes, of course. But now that you have propounded your theory, what do you propose to do about the controversy you have created?
Dumier: The best thing I can do. Just keep cooking and serving wine at my wonderful Michelin-rated restaurant. I must leave the scientific souffl? I have whipped up at the Sorbonne and elsewhere to the scientists.
NewsLaugh: What if your theory is refuted?
Dumier: Refuted for whom, monsieur? Never for me! Whatever the experts decide, I will continue to believe that you cannot have a proper Theory of Evolution unless you make a primary place for the necessity of food and, later, for the delights of wine.
NewsLaugh: Thank you, Chef Dumier. It has been a pleasure talking with you.
Dumier: You're most welcome. But, my good man, talk about pleasure, may I invite you to stay for dinner? This evening I am making some of my exquisite roti du boef, which will go quite well with an elegant Bordeaux.
About the Author
Tom Attea, creator of NewsLaugh.com, has had six shows produced Off-Broadway and has written comedy for TV. Critics have called his writing ""delightfully funny" and "witty" with "good, genuine laughs."
Thoughts about Cabernet Sauvignon
Ancient Biblical Grape Juice And Wine Drinkers, Raisin Eaters And Teetotalers (part 2) Scriptures (mostly Old Testament) Forbidding Wine Drinking
There were anointed men of the Bible who took an oath; that they would not drink wine or eat or drink any of the products of a grapevine, including fr...
Click Here to Read More About Wine ...
Cabernet Sauvignon Products we recommend
Domaine de Jaugaret St. Julien
The Fillastre family has owned this small property in Bourdeaux sin 1654. The Domaine has some of the oldest vines in St. Julien - some of the Malbec vines are well past 100 years old. Mr Fillastre usually ages his wine, which is made from 70% Cabernet Sauvignon, 25% Merlot and 5% Malbec, in oak barrells for 28 months to 3 years creating a huge wine! When asked to describe his wine Mr. Fillastre says, "It is good." We on the other hand describe this French wine as having a brilliant ruby color with a nose of ripe burnt fruit and spice along with coffee and tobacco. The palate has richness, structure with wonderful finesse and elegance. We believe this dry red wine is a truly great find for our customers. Great gift! DJSJ00 DJSJ00
Price: 89.99 USD
News about Cabernet Sauvignon
My College Sweetheart
Fri, 11 Apr 2008 15:57:38 PDT
A year and a half ago, I wrote a series of entries about Kennedy. Our freshman year of college had just finished and we were what I called then an “unlikely duo”. She is many things to me: my first and most significant girl crush, an authority figure who I am more likely to listen to than anyone else (my mother included), and nowadays a kind of sister. “Best friend” always seems inadequate. We were supposed to go to Europe together that freshman summer but through a combination of my own irres
Vinturi Wine Aerator
Fri, 11 Apr 2008 20:02:56 PDT
If you are a wine-lover, then this product is a must have. In every circumstance, with each wine, mixing just the right amount of air with your wine at the precise moments. This see-through aerator grants your reds or whites to breath instantly. The Vinturi Wine Aerator results are a better bouquet, enhanced flavor, and a smoother finish.
Fri, 11 Apr 2008 23:42:22 PDT
i'm totally addicted to History and please dont ask me why. went to Bedok Library with Nazurah after our breakfast and maths class just now. i saw this book about Rasputin and i was singing to the song ms seet made us listen to. hahahahahha. the way Rasputin dressed is , urgh! it haunt me. mid year, can you like postpone yourself or something? try finding the song titled Rasputin by Bonny M, i think. Rasputin There lived a certain man in Russia long ago He was big and strong, in his eyes a fl
Is your cabernet a fake? (MSN Money Canada)
Sat, 12 Apr 2008 21:08:41 PDT
Wine is the latest target for counterfeiters, so technology companies like Kodak and Hewlett-Packard are getting into the act to put a pedigree on your pinot.
Grove shop abounds in decadent pet accessories (Miami Herald)
Sun, 13 Apr 2008 00:11:10 PDT
If you're an animal lover, Woody Neilsen's Pet Gallery is going to draw you in when you look in the window and spot a $1,400 fur piano that's a feline scratching post and plays Memories from the Broadway musical Cats.
Sun, 13 Apr 2008 07:00:42 PDT
I’m doing sort of a lather, rinse, revise, repeat thing for the last few posts leading up to my 1000th post on theophrast.us. Here’s one of my short stories that appeared in The Harrow in 2006, and is--to date--the only time I have written a childbirth scene. Always Becoming It was the clouds, something in the clouds that convinced Mozell her own death was near. Wispy strips of transientness coming down from the North, catching the sunlight, thickening into wide bands of gold that crossed
Confessions of a Bitter Dead Ender
Sun, 13 Apr 2008 07:48:52 PDT
I live in a small town in the Midwest and I am bitter. It wasn’t always like that. Before the mill shut down I was a happy consumer of organic teas and lover of fine wines and Asian fusion food. We used to sit in the local Latte Shop and talk endlessly about wine regions, vintages, terroir, and tannins of our favorite cabernets.......>>
Wine Stoppers | Wine Storage
Labels: Aging Wine | April Wine&type=page">